reviews · Topics/Discussion

Proto Sci-Fi: From the Earth to the Moon / #scifimonth

For my reading challenge Dancing with Fantasy & Sci-Fi I created three sections. Fantasy, Sci-Fi and Generic. Each had their own prompts. One of the prompts of the sci-fi section was Proto Sci-Fi.

Proto Sci-Fi,  you ask, what is that? Technically these are books written before a certain time period that can be considered sci-fi when looking back. There is some debate on where proto sci-fi really starts. Some say at H.G. Wells so any books before 1890. Others go by Frankenstein by Mary Shelley which would be books before 1818. It is quite something to read a book from the 1700s so books before 1890 is where I kept this prompt for.

From the Earth to the Moon

My own choice for this challenge was From the Earth to the Moon by Jules Verne. One of the Extraordinary Travel books and the first book in the Gun Club series. I had never read anything by Jules Verne before that I recall (and one would think I’d recall that). However this seemed like the obvious choice for Proto Sci-Fi. Moon, space, before 1890.

My experience with this book was interesting. This book is very science heavy and from what I have been told this is one of the science heaviest books by him which seems to put off even some of the biggest Jules Verne fans.  Especially the start was quite a bit to get through. The first 50-80 pages were a bit of a slog. The science was info dumpy and at times hard to follow. And sometimes just plain boring.

However inbetween the science I really could appreciate what Verne was doing. Realizing this book was written in 1865, his theories and science are quite a feat. It was what kept my attention. Can you imagine creating such a large cannon as to shoot a misile at the moon? That creation I also found highly entertaining. From earthquakes to weather changes.

Once we got through that science portion was when it truly got interesting. Where the adventure was really about to start and the decision for a human crew was made. Limiting the story after that to 3 people really did the story a great service. It became so much more focused and we got to get a better glimpse at the characters we barely got time to meet during all the science.

It was not the easiest read all together but seeing the ideas and theories from so many years ago was very much an enrichment to my reading life.

More Proto Sci-Fi?

So does this step into older sci-fi make me want to pick up more? I think so yes. I certainly want to read more Jules Verne over the coming years. If this was one of his more heavier science books I think I should be fine with the others.

Of course I have already read Frankenstein and have read some H.G. Wells and Robert Louis Stevenson. Beyond that I think I’ll be selective. The Man in the Moone seems like a good pick as that was what influenced Verne to write From the Earth to the Moon. The Blazing World I am also intrigued by. And of course New Atlantis.

Will I read this quickly? Probably not. But I will over time.

Is there any proto sci-fi on your tbr list?

Kopie van Ontwerp zonder titel(1)

9 thoughts on “Proto Sci-Fi: From the Earth to the Moon / #scifimonth

  1. I read 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea one summer when I was a preteen and hated it, ha ha. When we moved out to the country I only got to go to the library every two weeks when I had my visitations with my father, and I always ended up reading all of my books before I got to go back and I was stuck reading books from the house library. I haven’t read anything by Verne since! I should give this one a try next year since I am considering classic books to be 50+ years old for my reading challenge. 🌛

    I have never read Frankenstein and I am also reading that one next year, too. 📚

    Thanks for sharing your review, and for the extra information on Proto-Science Fiction! 👍✨

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Did you read the one with all the info or the one where the babbling was taking out? I’ve gathered there is a big change in enjoyment then haha.

      This one is for sure a lot tighter/shorter than 20 000 leagues is so a good place to grab him again.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I’ve wanted to read From the Earth to the Moon for the longest time, especially since I found out years ago that Space Mountain in Disneyland Paris used to be based on it, haha. I do have some proto-sci-fi on my TBR here and there, and I have Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde on my immediate TBR. I think some people consider it to be more horror than sci-fi but it has science in it, so I consider it to be sci-fi.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply to lydiaschoch Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.