A Pinch of Magic / Book Review

Thank you to Netgalley and Simon and Schuster UK for the review copy in exchange for an honest review.

Book: A Pinch of Magic by Michelle Harrison
Release Date: February 7th 2019
Tags: Fantasy / Middle Grade / Curse / Siblings / Sisters / Tower / Magical Objects / Time Travel
Trigger Warnings: Mentioned Suicide / Attempted Suicide



Reading Challenge(10)

Three sisters trapped by an ancient curse.
Three magical objects with the power to change their fate.
Will they be enough to break the curse?
Or will they lead the sisters even deeper into danger?

Reading Challenge(11)

While I don’t read it as often as I like, Middle Grade fantasy books can be such gems. A Pinch of Magic was one of those for me. When I requested this book there was no cover yet so you can’t accuse me of being lured in by the cover which you have to admit is just gorgeous. I was lured by the synopsis of three sisters and three magical objects.

While this book is in theory about 3 sisters it focuses all its attention on the middle sister, 13 year old Betty. With her 6 year old sister Charlie she tries to sneak across the water to a nearby city for the Halloween celebrations. But as they are leaving the harbor of their town on a boat their grandmother, and caretaker, appears out of nowhere, dragging them back. Betty isn’t having any of it anymore though and demands to know why they are never allowed to leave the town. That is when grandma spills the beans. They are cursed.

Harrison can write. This books is beautifully written. No sentence is even remotely misplaced. We are swept up in the story with Betty and feel for her when she is so held back by her grandma and then learns about the curse. All her dreams, crushed. The book is full of magic and it is great to read about.

While I am rating this book 4,5 stars I do have some complaints. While I think Betty is a rather well rounded characters, I can’t quite say the same for her older sister Fliss who is 16 years old. I feel like she gets the short end of the stick with being characterized as boy crazy and falls very in line to her 3 year younger sisters demands. I can’t quite say that much more about her. That is a shame.  I also have one little twitch about the world building as I would have liked a better explanation on how exactly the magical items were created.

However beyond that this story is just a great feel good magic filled story. Great for young and old readers alike. I did see on goodreads that there might be a sequel. The current story wraps up fine however and can easily be read as a standalone. I think that is important, especially in middle grade.

5 thoughts on “A Pinch of Magic / Book Review

  1. I really have a problem with suicides in Middle Grade. I haven’t read any where it was handled well, if thats even possible, so I don’t know what that would look like. I would be curious to read this to see how it was included. Thanks for sharing your thoughts in this one. 👍✨

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I felt iffy on the suicide too. But it was mentioned and in scene it was stopped of sort. It would still be interesting to see how someone of age would respond or feel about that though.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Two of the MGs I read had the MCs attempt suicide more for the attention, or the “I’ll show them how much they’ll miss me” scenario, and they both came out of it unscathed, and, of course, got a lot of attention. I think that is dangerous because it gives kids that idea. I wish I could remember the one author, who was also school psychologist, who said there’s no rhyme or reason for it in MG because those who don’t know, shouldn’t, and those who do know shouldn’t be asked to relive it through a book. The two others were parent suicides, and as you know… I don’t think that’s ever appropriate in MG because of the nature of 7-11 year olds’ family safety worry mindset. It’s just giving more thing to have worry and have anxiety over for no real reason. 😞

        Liked by 1 person

I welcome your thoughts and opinions!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.